Louisville Realtor Reviews & Client Testimonials - GarrettsRealty.com

Find us on...


Login using...

New Search X

Garretts Realty Group - Realtor Reviews

At Garretts Realty Group – Coldwell Banker McMahan Co., we pride ourselves on our customer care. By receiving reviews and testimonials from our past clients here in Louisville it is truly a gift of thanks. Below you will find some of our most recent Realtor reviews.

Garretts Realty Reviews and Testimonials

Read client reviews about the top agents here at Garretts Realty Group - Coldwell Banker McMahan Co. Learn more about the great experiences our customers have had during buying or selling their homes. We currently have 26 reviews with an average review score of 5 out of 5 stars.


List of Client Testimonials & Reviews

Was going to try and find a house on my own as a DIY type guy but was introduced as a friend of a friend. Thankfully. Ed is a wealth of knowledge (nearly a quarter century worth) not only in the industry but about area builders and techniques as well as details about homes in general (never stumped him on even molding types). I felt very lucky to have found Ed and luckier to now be writing this review in the house of my dreams he was so patient in finding me.


My husband and I decided to buy our first home in Louisville. We were transferring from Florida due to the Coast Guard, so our realtor had to be patient and flexible during the process. Ed was a great person and realtor to work with! A lot of times he was informed last minute, yet he always came through. We are grateful for the opportunity to work with him and could not be more happy with our home. Definitely recommend his service!

Brittany C

Ed found our house in 1996 and then helped sell it again in 2015. Would recommend Ed to anyone looking to buy or sell in Louisville, Ky or surrounding Counties. He took the time and patients with us to get it done. If you are looking to buy or sell give him a call.

Wendy B

Very helpful in selling my property. I was already moved to California and he handled all the issues that came up regarding my property. If you are looking for a honesty, hard working realtor, I highly recommend Ed. He will do what it takes to help sell your property!!


We were selling and buying at the same time. We couldn’t have done it without Garretts Realty Group! They made everything go very smooth and with us having three children they were very flexible and worked around our schedule so that we could do everything needed and view homes. The pictures done on our house we Sold were phenomenal we got a contract within 5 days of it being listed. We found a beautiful home for our family thanks to this group we couldn’t have managed all that without them. We would highly recommend them to anyone that needs their services.

Jennifer M

Ed helped my wife Patti and I during a rough transition from Evansville to Louisville due to our job changes. We were having to commute back and forth daily and try to find a place in Louisville that we could also bring all of our animals. We called on him almost daily and he came through every time with some really great prospects until we found our home in Germantown neighborhood. If it weren’t for Ed making us aware of putting a backup offer on the house we would’ve lost it. It was difficult finding a home in the area we were wanting because houses tend to go fast when put on the market….one day a new listing, next day we go to see the place and find there is a contract already. It became even more stressful, but Ed got us through.

Jeffery W

I cannot recommend Ed and Nathan Garrett highly enough. They have gone out of their way in a multitude of ways to make sure I was able to purchase my dream home and to assist with the sale of my previous home. They are conscientious, courteous, proactive, personable and made the whole experience fantastic!

Becky G

I enjoyed working with Ed Garrett he kept me up to date during the complete process. So much so that I have bought or sold 4 properties with Ed so far


Ed Garrett and his team are AWESOME to work with. With his help we looked at over 30 homes. We were very picky and knew exactly what we wanted and the price range we wanted to stay within. Ed did not pressure us into a home we weren’t completely happy with. In addition, being a Veteran I used my VA loan. Ed has extensive experience in working with Veterans and the requirements of securing VA financing. I whole heartedly endorse Ed Garrett and his team of highly skilled real estate agents. He truly made home buying easy and enjoyable for me and my family. If you are looking for an honest and hard working agent, look no further!

Ken J

Ed was responsive and always “had our backs”. The house purchase had several issues that arose. Ed was on top of them and always helpful. He answered all our questions and when there were issues about the repairs done to the home, he furnished a home warranty for us. I would recommend him to others in the future.


Wonderful and easy to get along with. Helped my husband and I close on our first house just in time to welcome our newest baby! Even when we ran into unexpected issues he was there to help and answer any questions we had. We couldn’t be more thankful!

Emily P

Nathan and Ed Garrett went way above and beyond to not just find me a house, but the perfect one for me. Then it was time to sell my old house and they spent countless hours answering every single question and making sure that not only did I understand the process, but walked me through all my best options. If you are looking for realtors who will go out of their way to make the entire process personal and professional from start to finish, Garrett is the way to go!


Ed Garrett was the best realtor I could have found, I really got luck with Ed. He thoroughly explained the home buying process to me and showed great patience with me while showing me over 20 homes. I truly felt Ed had my best interest at heart and would recommend him and Garrett’s Realty group to anyone buying or selling a home. Thanks Ed!!

Erika H

Garretts Realty Group was easy to work with and got my house sold quickly. They helped out every step of the way and made the process very smooth. Highly recommend.

Matt S.

Ed was a life-saver for me. I had my house on the market for a year after I moved to Texas from Kentucky. It was a long stressful time trying to get this sold. But Ed stuck by me. He worked hard to get all necessary repairs done, find buyers that would work with me, and then even worked with the bank to ensure we got offers they would accept. He was there for me no matter what to answer any and all questions I had. I would highly recommend him to anyone needing to buy or sell a home!

Tracy P

Provides excellent selling techniques and follow through to the end of Real Estate transactions. He has a great personality along with remarkable ethics. He was able to sell 2 properties from 2 different estates, both of which were extremely difficult properties to sale. He produced excellent results were several other reality companies failed.

Dee Dee J

We can't say enough about the positive experiences we have had with Garrett's Realty. We first met Ed when our son bought and sold a house. The turnaround on both houses was very quick and the selling price was more than they were asking! When we were first looking to buy a house in the area, Ed was always available to show us everything we requested at the times we needed. He was so helpful in making our move a smooth one. We recently found a house for sale closer to our grandchildren so I called Ed and asked him to sell our home right away. He and Nathan immediately listed it, took pictures and produced a wonderful marketing video. They sold it in three days! Ed went above and beyond to make sure both the selling and buying of the two houses went off without any problems. We don't plan to move again but if we ever do we will most definitely use Garrett's Realty.

Diane Still

Ed Garrett helped my find my first house and now is helping with the second. He is very honest and doesn’t pressure you into buying just so he can get a sale. In my opinion he’s the best realtor there is!!

Jesse S

Ed has been so helpful and knowledgeable throughout the process of our first home buying experience. With my husband being in the Marine Corps and stationed in Japan he helped me with everything that needed to be done and beyond. He made sure I understood the process and answered all my question and concerns. I highly recommend him if you want to have a piece of mind home buying experience.

Anika C

My husband and I were looking to purchase a home and Nathan Garrett with Garrett Realty reached out to us and worked with us to find out exactly what we wanted in a home. We told him what we where looking for in a home and he let us know via email, text and phone call when a home was on the market to fit our criteria. We have now purchased a home after working with Nathan and thanks to him, he was able to find us exactly the house we were seeking! He was prompt, professional and he made closing on the home effortless on our end. We will use him again if we decide to purchase another home in the future and we will refer him to family and friends!

Melissa O'Bryan

Nathan was very helpful, got back with me when he said he would. Very impressed with the time frame it took to sell. This is the second property he has sold for me. I will highly recommend him to future real estate transactions.

Philip B

Ed knows his business, knows the people in the area, and knows how to make the transaction smooth, and easy. Good humored, he’s easy to work with, and easy (and available) to talk to.


It has been 6 months since my husband and I decided to start the process of building a new home. We have three small children (smallest was 3 weeks old at the time) and we were quickly outgrowing our starter home. We were very nervous about the process and transitions but Nathan and Ed were amazing to work with and they made the process as easy for us as possible. They went above and beyond to do everything they could for us and in the past 6 months we have sold and closed on 2 properties!! Now, our next step is to build our forever home. We couldn’t have been more happy with the service that they provided to us and I would recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell!

Mallory T

My house was listed on a Friday afternoon and had a full price offer that same evening – site unseen. Their photography skills and marketing really brought out the true beauty of my home and in turn is the reason it also had 9 showings in one day. Thank you guys!

Amanda S

Ed worked with us for a long time looking for just the right house for our needs/wants. He was always prompt getting back to us and scheduling viewings…and we saw ALOT of houses. Really appreciate all of his help through the entire process!


Nathan was dedicated to the sale of my condo and always available to answer any questions I had. He went above and beyond to make sure the execution of this sale was flawless. I couldn't be happier and will use Garretts Realty in the future just as I have in the past!

Tara S

Working with Garrets Realty Group to sell our home and buy a new one was awesome. They took wonderful pictures of our home for the listing, and the listing they put together generated a lot of interest. There were houses in our neighborhood that had been for sale for a year or more, but with the great looking listing they put together and their advice on proper pricing, we had multiple viewings and multiple offers within about a week. When it came to finding us a new home, Ed’s knowledge and expertise helped lead us to a great deal on an amazing home in a location we couldn’t be happier with. We have some family considering moving to the Oldham county area as well, and when they’re ready to seriously start looking, they will also be be working with Garretts Realty Group based on our recommendation.

Jason S

Very kind and committed to finding you the right house or your family. He worked hard everyday looking for the house to fit our needs. Never getting frustrated when we did not like a house

Misty L